Why does intake keep slipping?
- Inquiries arrive in four places: the website form, the main inbox, voicemail and referrals to individual lawyers.
- There are no written criteria. If the rules are in a partner’s head, only the partner can sort.
- Staff don’t know what they’re allowed to say. Afraid of giving advice, they say nothing until a lawyer has read it.
- The form invites the whole story. You collect confidential detail you didn’t need, before checking conflicts.
- Declines never go out. An unclear silence can leave someone believing you’re looking after their matter.
How do you fix it yourself?
1. Write your intake rules on one page. Practice areas you take, the states and counties you work in, matters you never take, and what counts as urgent (a court date, a filing deadline, someone in danger). Add a referral list for everything else, such as your state or local bar’s lawyer referral service. A lawyer at the firm approves the page.
2. Decide what you’ll collect before the conflict check, and nothing more. Usually the person’s name and contact details, the names of the other parties, the type of matter, the location, and any deadline. Not the full story. The Florida Bar’s Opinion 24-1 on generative AI (advisory, and written for Florida lawyers) quotes the comment to its Rule 4-1.18: a consultation is likely to have occurred when a lawyer invites information about a possible representation “without clear and reasonably understandable warnings and cautionary statements that limit the lawyer’s obligations,” and a person responds. Your own state’s rule and your ethics counsel decide the wording of your form.
3. Build the form in Google Forms. Go to forms.google.com, select Blank form and name it. Add your questions from step 2 and the warning text your lawyer approved at the top. Google says you can store responses in a Google Sheet, which gives you one running intake list with timestamps. Put the form on your website’s contact page in place of the open message box.
4. Route everything to one labeled place in Gmail. In Gmail, click the search options icon in the search box, enter criteria that catch your form notifications and your intake address, select Create filter, choose to apply a label (and star it if you like), then Create filter again. Check afterwards that older inquiries are labeled too, and sort any that aren’t by hand once.
5. Write three replies in advance, approved by a lawyer. An acknowledgment that says when the firm will be in touch and that no lawyer-client relationship exists yet; a referral reply for matters you don’t take; and an urgent-matter reply that tells the person how and when a lawyer will call. None of them answers the legal question.
6. Check the intake list twice a day. One person sorts new rows into “fits, run conflicts,” “refer,” “urgent” and “spam or solicitation,” and replies with the matching message.
What are your options?
| Option | What it looks like | Who runs it | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Do it yourself | A short form, a Gmail label, approved replies, a twice-daily check | A paralegal or office manager | Evenings and busy days; staff unsure what they may say |
| Buy a tool | Legal intake or CRM software with forms, follow-ups and booking | Your staff, inside the tool | Setup time, and whether its chat or texts meet your state’s rules |
| Hire a freelancer | A virtual receptionist or intake service | The service | What their staff say on the phone, and how they protect what they hear |
| Bring in an outside team | An AI worker set up around your written intake rules, within limits a lawyer approves | The team, with a lawyer deciding every matter | Who is accountable for what it says, and how you see every message |
What can an AI worker do, and what stays with a lawyer?
| An AI worker can do | Keep with a lawyer |
|---|---|
| Acknowledge every inquiry quickly, saying it’s an automated assistant, not a lawyer | Whether to take the matter |
| Ask the factual questions your intake page lists, and nothing else | Conflict decisions |
| Sort inquiries by practice area, location and urgency, using your rules | Any answer to “do I have a case?” or “what should I do?” |
| Send your approved referral reply to matters you don’t take | Fees, engagement letters and non-engagement letters |
| Alert a named lawyer at once when an inquiry mentions a deadline or danger | Anything urgent, emotional or involving someone at risk |
| Book consultations into the lawyer’s calendar for matters that fit | What to tell someone already represented by another lawyer |
The line it must never cross is legal advice. The Florida opinion describes guidance for nonlawyer intake staff that fits an AI worker well: identify their nonlawyer status, limit questions to factual information, and “not offer any legal advice concerning the prospective client’s matter,” referring legal questions to the lawyer. It also says chatbots that talk to prospective clients must disclose that they are an AI program and not a lawyer or employee of the firm. The opinion says advisory ethics opinions are not binding, and it speaks to Florida lawyers; check your own state bar’s guidance with your ethics counsel. When someone asks a legal question, the AI worker should say a lawyer will answer it, and pass it on. It will sometimes misjudge a message, so a lawyer should review its sorting closely until its record on your own inquiries is clear.
Confidentiality starts before anyone is a client. The same opinion tells lawyers to research an AI program’s policies on data retention, data sharing and self-learning before using it. Ask where inquiries are stored, who can see them, whether they’re used to train any model, and how they’re deleted when you’re done.
Operator is the AI worker we run. The law firm page covers intake alongside document chasing and invoice follow-up.
FAQ
Can an AI worker tell someone whether they have a case? No. That’s legal advice. It can collect the facts your intake rules ask for and pass them to a lawyer, who decides what to say.
Does a website form create a lawyer-client relationship? It can create duties to a prospective client, depending on what the form invites and what warnings it gives. Ask your ethics counsel or your state bar’s ethics hotline about your form’s wording.
Should the AI worker run conflict checks? It can search your client list for the names it collected and show a lawyer the results. Deciding whether there’s a conflict stays with a lawyer.
What about phone calls? Voicemails and call notes should land in the same intake list as the form, so one set of rules applies to every inquiry, however it arrived.
Sources
- Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (generative AI), The Florida Bar,
- How to use Google Forms, Google Docs Editors Help,
- Create rules to filter your emails, Gmail Help,